Halfway down Rendezvous Bay, Sunshine Shack is the kind of beach bar that turns first-timers into regulars — and USA Today's 10Best just named it the #2 Best Caribbean Beach Bar of 2026. Run by Garvey, one of the warmest characters on the island, it's all hammocks, a play area for the kids, plastic chairs in the sand, and a grill turning out BBQ lobster, chicken, ribs and fresh snapper, all finished with his famous Awesome Sauce. No pretense, no dress code — just rum punch, coconut cocktails, and that easy island rhythm. It's pulled in everyone from New York yuppies to longtime locals, and once you've been, you'll understand why. Live music Tuesdays and Sundays keeps the afternoons going, and the Shack also hosts private events for those who want the whole place to themselves.