Grilled lobster straight off the barbecue, fresh crayfish, and the strongest rum punch in Anguilla — served barefoot on one of the cay's little sandy beaches, with nothing but turquoise water all around. The Wallace family has been running Gorgeous Scilly Cay for 40 years, and the lunch menu shows it: simple, fresh, and unmistakably Caribbean. Open Tuesday to Sunday, 11am to 5:30pm.
Tip: the map below shows the departure pier in Island Harbour — that's where you'll head first. Give them a call, or just ask one of the boatmen at the pier — someone will take you across.